New York Pizza & Pasta Stopped Losing Loyal Customers to DoorDash. Here’s How

Owner: Alex and Andrew | Operational Since: 1998

A Pleasant Hill Institution With a Growing Problem

For years, New York Pizza & Pasta has been the go-to spot in Pleasant Hill for handcrafted pies and hearty Italian-American comfort food. They built their reputation the old-fashioned way: great ingredients, generous portions, and a dining room that always felt like home.

But the restaurant business doesn't stand still. And as delivery culture exploded, the owner noticed something quietly alarming. Customers who used to call in or order directly were disappearing from their own channels.

The margins were holding. The food quality was the same. But the relationship with customers? That was slowly being handed over to a middleman.

The Wake-Up Call: A Conversation with Tony

It wasn’t a slow month or a dip in orders that sounded the alarm. It was a regular customer named Tony.

Tony had been ordering from New York Pizza & Pasta for years. But one day, in casual conversation, he mentioned that he had switched to ordering through DoorDash. Not because the food was any different. Not because he liked DoorDash more. Simply because it was easier. The app was slick and delivery was built right in.

That single conversation hit harder than any sales report could. If Tony had made the switch, how many other loyal regulars had quietly done the same?

Every order going through DoorDash meant giving away 25–30% in commissions. Every customer ordering through a third-party app was a customer whose data, loyalty, and repeat business now belonged to someone else's platform.

Alex knew it was time to fight back, on their own terms.

The VoiceBit Solution: Bringing Customers Back to Your Table

When New York Pizza & Pasta came to VoiceBit, the ask was clear: make direct ordering as easy as DoorDash, or even easier. No more clunky web forms. No more putting customers on hold to take a phone order. Just a seamless, branded experience that keeps revenue where it belongs.

We built a solution specifically designed for restaurants like theirs:

• Cuisine-Specific Web Ordering – A beautifully designed, mobile-friendly online ordering experience built around their actual menu, from build-your-own pies to pasta combos. Customers get the same ease they love on DoorDash, but they're ordering directly.

• Integrated Direct Delivery – Delivery is now handled through their own system. No third-party commission. No sharing customer data. Every delivery order is a direct sale.

• Streamlined Phone Ordering – Automated phone ordering means no more missed calls during rushes, no staff tied up reading back order details, and no customers left on hold.

• Unified Revenue Dashboard – One view of all incoming orders: web, phone, and delivery, so nothing falls through the cracks.

The Results: Numbers That Tell the Story

Before VoiceBit	After VoiceBit
❌ Loyal customers drifting to DoorDash for convenience	✅ Direct web ordering as easy and fast as any third-party app
❌ 25–30% margin lost on every third-party order	✅ 100% of delivery revenue stays in-house
❌ Phone orders slow, error-prone, and staff-heavy	✅ Automated phone ordering: accurate, fast, and always available
❌ No visibility into delivery orders or customer patterns	✅ Single dashboard tracking all orders, revenue, and customer data

The Business Impact

🍕 Recaptured direct delivery revenue – commissions that used to go to DoorDash now stay in the business

⏱️ 10 minutes saved per phone order – automated ordering handles the entire transaction

📈 15% average increase in ticket size – smart menu prompts and upsells built into the web ordering flow

👥 Customer data back in their hands – every direct order builds a customer profile they own and can market to

In Their Own Words

"When Tony told me he had switched to DoorDash just because it was easier to use, I knew we had a problem we could actually fix. VoiceBit gave us a web ordering experience that our customers actually want to use. Now when Tony orders, that order comes straight to us. No middleman, no commission, no excuses."

– Alex, New York Pizza & Pasta, Pleasant Hill

Ready to fix your Web and Phone ordering?

👉 14-day free trial, no questions asked.

Start delivering your 5-star phone experience at scale today. Book a free demo👇👇👇